Skip to main content

Parallel University: Selection Sunday

Somewhere out there, if the many-world interpretation of quantum mechanics is correct, it is still Selection Sunday.  Somewhere, all of the conference tournaments are now complete, including the Big Ten Tournament, which in the particular parallel universe that I am following finished with a final of:

No 2. seed Michigan State defeats No. 9 seed Michigan 79-60

Much like the first game this year at Breslin, MSU dominated. Winston scored a game high 24 points and eight assists, with Tillman chipping in 18 points and 13 rebounds.  Rocket Watts had a strong performance as well, chipping in 12 points and four rebounds.  For the second year in a row, MSU wins both the regular season and conference Big Ten crowns.

Just a few minutes after the Spartans finished cutting down the nets once again in Indy, the Selection Committee starts rolling out the brackets, starting with the Midwest, and No. 1 overall seed, Kansas.


Similar to last year, MSU learns their fate almost immediately, and also similar to last year, they find themselves as the No. 2 seed in the same region as the No 1 overall seed.  Most prognosticators had MSU as a No. 3 seed, but the fact that MSU won the Big Ten Tournament seemed to give them enough of a boost slide into the No. 2 seed line over a team like Midwest No. 3 seed Villanova, who lost to Creighton in the Big East Tournament Final.

Looking at this bracket quickly, it is hard not to notice that three of last year's Final Four all wound up in the same first weekend pod in Cleveland, including a rematch of the National Title game.  Just like last year, Virginia is the higher seed and presumed favorite over Texas Tech.  MSU draws surprise MAC champion Ohio in Cleveland in first round action.  That could get interesting...

It is also notable that MSU could wind up facing No. 6 seed Iowa in the Sweet 16.  With ten total Big Ten teams qualifying for the Tournament, it was inevitable that a few Big Ten teams would wind up in the same half of a region.  Considering that MSU only played Iowa once this year, it was a natural pairing.

It is also notable that BYU was placed in the Tampa pod in the Midwest, almost due to necessity.  BYU refuses to play on Sundays, and so they could only be placed into the West or Midwest Regions.  As Gonzaga (as we will see later) was selected as the No. 1 seed in the West and BYU is the second team selected from the West Coast Conference, seeding principles dictate that the top two teams in the same conference should be placed in different regions.  There was only one option remaining.

Following the reveal of the Midwest bracket, it's time for the South Region, and its No. 1 seed (and No. 2 seed overall), Baylor.


Despite their close loss to Kansas in the Big 12 Championship game, the Committee decided to grant Baylor the No. 2 overall seed.  Big East champ, Creighton, is the No. 2 seed and Duke checked in as the No. 3 seed.  Dick Vitale immediately picked Duke to make the Final Four.

The South Region also contained three Big Ten teams: No. 4 seed Wisconsin, No. 6 seed Michigan, and No. 10 seed Indiana.  The fans in Ann Arbor were irate that they were not given a higher seed after upsetting Wisconsin in the Big Ten semifinal.  A peak at the final seed list showed that the Wolverines were supposed to be the weakest No. 5 seed, but do to a surprisingly high number of potential rematches that could occur in the second round, Michigan was dropped to a No. 6 seed.  Now, a potential second round show down with Duke and Michigan in Greensboro looms.

Moving on, the Committee next revealed the brackets for the West Region.



As expected, West Coast Conference champions, Gonzaga, claimed the No. 1 seed and San Diego State was given the No. 2 seed.  SEC Champs Kentucky was also placed in the this region.  Dick Vitale immediately picked Kentucky to make the Final Four as well.

The West Region also showed the first pair of bubble teams to make the First Four:  Xavier and Richmond.  The two former A-10 rivals will meet on Tuesday night in Dayton for a chance to take on West Virginia on Friday in Greensboro.

The West Region also features three teams from the Big Ten: No. 5 seed Ohio State, No. 7 seed Illinois, and No. 9 seed Rutgers, who is making their first tournament appearance since 1991 and seeking their first win since 1983.

Finally, as bubble teams like NC State, Stanford, UCLA, Cincinnati, and Texas held their breath, the East Region was announced.


As expected, the Dayton Flyers were given the final No. 1 seed, marking by far their highest seed ever.  Their previous high was a No. 4 seed in 2003. The East Region also featured No. 2 seed Florida State and No. 3 seed Seton Hall.

Also in the East Region, the remaining pair of bubble teams: Stanford and Cincinnati were revealed, bursting the bubble of teams like UCLA, NC State, and Texas.  Fortunately, the NIT is also taking place in a parallel university somewhere...

As for Big Ten teams, the East Region featured No. 4 seed Maryland and No. 6 seed Penn State, who earned their first tournament bid since 2011, and who will be seeking their first win since their magical run to the Sweet 16 in 2001.

As with any Selection Sunday, the revealing of the bracket is certain to stimulate a lot of debate and analysis.  In the parallel universe, that will still take place and we will get a glimpse of it in the next few days.  Stay tuned.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dr. Green and White Helps You Fill Out Your Bracket (2024 Edition)

For as long as I can remember, I have loved the NCAA Basketball Tournament. I love the bracket. I love the underdogs. I love One Shining Moment. I even love the CBS theme music. As a kid I filled out hand-drawn brackets and scoured the morning newspaper for results of late night games. As I got older, I started tracking scores using a increasing complex set of spreadsheets. Over time, as my analysis became more sophisticated, I began to notice certain patterns to the Madness I have found that I can use modern analytics and computational tools to gain a better understanding of the tournament itself and perhaps even extract some hints as to how the tournament might play out. Last year, I used this analysis to correctly predict that No. 4 seed UConn win the National Title in addition to other notable upsets. There is no foolproof way to dominate your office pool, but it is possible to spot upsets that are more likely than others and teams that are likely to go on a run or flame out early.

The Case for Optimism

In my experience there are two kinds of Michigan State fans. First, there are the pessimists. These are the members of the Spartan fan base who always expect the worst. Any amount of success for the Green and White is viewed to be a temporary spat of good luck. Even in the years when Dantonio was winning the Rose Bowl and Izzo was going to the Final Four, dark times were always just around the bend. Then, there are the eternal optimists. This part of the Spartan fan base always bets on the "over." These fans expect to go to, and win, and bowl games every year. They expect that the Spartans can win or least be competitive in every game on the schedule. The optimists believe that Michigan State can be the best Big Ten athletic department in the state. When it comes to the 2023 Michigan State football team, the pessimists are having a field day. A major scandal, a fired head coach, a rash of decommitments, and a four-game losing streak will do that. Less than 24 months after hoi

2023 Final Playoff and New Year's Six Predictions

The conference championships have all been played and, in all honesty, last night's results were the absolute worst-case scenario for the Selection Committee. Michigan and Washington will almost certainly be given the No. 1 and No. 2 seed and be placed in the Sugar Bowl and the Rose Bowl respectively. But there are four other teams with a reasonable claim on the last two spots and I have no idea what the committee is going to do. Florida State is undefeated, but the Seminoles played the weakest schedule of the four candidates and their star quarterbac (Jordan Travis) suffered a season ending injury in the second-to-last game of the regular season. Florida State is outside of the Top 10 in both the FPI and in my power rankings. I also the Seminoles ranked No. 5 in my strength of record metric, behind two of the other three candidates. Georgia is the defending national champions and were previously ranked No. 1 coming into the week. But after losing to Alabama in the SEC Title game,